Parent Category: Salafi Wahabies
Category: Tauheed & Shirk & Tawassul & Shafaat
Published on Friday, 03 August 2012 04:19
Written by Tears of Karbala
It was common CUSTOM of Sahaba to say "Ya Muhammad". Here one reference from Ibn Kathir (Al-Badaya wa al-Nahaya):
وحمل خالد بن الوليد حتى جاوزهم وسار لجبال مسيلمة وجعل يترقَّب أن يصل إليه فيقتله، ثمَّ رجع، ثمَّ وقف بين الصَّفين ودعا البراز وقال: أنا ابن الوليد العود، أنا ابن عامر وزيد، ثمَّ نادى بشعار المسلمين وكان شعارهم يومئذ: يا محمَّداه، وجعل لا يبرز لهم أحد إلا قتله، ولا يدنو منه شيء إلا أكله، ودارت رحى المسلمين،
Translation: ....When Khalid bin Walid fought with 60,000 men's army of Musailma Kadhab, the number of Muslims was very less. And they (muslims) faced so many hardships in this battle that were about to get defeat.
When Khalid bin Walid and some of his companions, who stood fast, saw that, they said:
“ثمہ نادیٰ بشعارالمسلمین وکان شعارھم یومئذٍ یا محمدہ“
... then they raised slogan according to CUSTOM of Muslims.... "YA MUHAMMAD"..... and as result Musailma was killed and Muslims got victory.
Questions for Ahle Hadith:
1. Were all these Sahaba "Mushriks"?
2. Why don't you put the fatwa of Shirk upon Ibn Kathir for recording this shirk in his book? (Note: There is big difference between recording "Weak Tradition" and recording "Shirk Tradition".
In fact, this shirk fatwa not only applies on Ibn Kathir, but also "Tabari" (who recorded this same tradition in his History in incidents of year of killing Musailma Kadhab.
And this same shirk fatwa goes to Ibn Athir too, who recorded it in his history , volume 2, page 152.